The poisonous whisper: Why every story should not be told

I didn’t grow up just eating meals at home. I grew up being fed with stories from the Ramayana, Mahabharata, Srimad Bhagavatam, and many other sources. In our family, values weren’t taught through strict instructions or warnings. They were passed down gently, through storytelling, layer by layer, like the folds of a soft blanket.

I never refrained from doing wrong out of fear of punishment or karma. I simply understood it shouldn’t be done. And that was enough.

The Stories That Shaped Me

As a little girl, I watched my grandmother, Patti, shed tears of joy and sorrow as she turned the pages of those ancient texts. Even today, it’s hard for me to read them in their original, chaste Tamil. But back then, I didn’t need to understand the words; I only had to look at her to know how deeply those stories moved her. And what they did to her, they slowly began to shape us too.

Our days never ended without a story, stories that taught us empathy, compassion, perseverance, love, forgiveness, and even leadership. 

While the Ramayana felt easier to understand, the Mahabharata was a completely different world, filled with complex characters, intricate plots, and numerous branching tales. It was a story within a story within a story. And yet, Patti could string them all together so beautifully. She would often repeat them too, until they became etched in our hearts.

Looking back, I know where my empathy comes from. From those stories. From her voice. From those moonlit dinners on the terrace, where we sat in a circle, food served not on plates but directly into our palms. A small ball of curd rice, a spoonful of spicy vathakozhambu over it, and a bit of story to go with every bite. 

One night, as we settled down for dinner, she said:

“You should never gossip or make quick judgments. Do you know what happened to Moor Patti—the old lady who sold buttermilk? It’s from one of the branching tales in the Mahabharata!”

We sat up eagerly.
“Tell us the story, Patti!”

And so, our Patti began:

The Moral of the Moor Patti

There once lived a noble king, known for his sincerity and devotion. After completing a sacred yagna, he personally invited learned sages and Vedic scholars to a grand feast. The food was prepared with utmost care. The atmosphere was one of reverence and joy. 

Just as the feast began, a hungry eagle flew overhead, holding a snake in its claws. The snake, struggling in its final moments, released venom, some of which fell into a pot of kheer (a sweet dish) below. No one noticed.

The king, with devotion and respect, served the kheer to the sages. Tragically, they all died after consuming it.

The heavens were in shock. Chitragupta, the divine accountant of karma, was left confused. Who was to be blamed?

 The eagle? It was only hunting.
The snake? It reacted in pain.
The cook? Unaware.
The king? Filled with love and intention.

Chitragupta turned to Lord Yama, the god of justice, for help. Yama smiled and said, “Observe the kingdom. The answer will reveal itself.”

Days passed. Disguised as a traveler, Chitragupta stopped at a small stall under a tree, run by an old woman selling buttermilk. As she prepared his drink, she asked where he was headed.
“To meet the king,” he replied.
The woman scoffed, “Why go to a murderer? He killed those sages. You might be next!”

And just like that, Chitragupta had his answer.

The karmic burden didn’t fall on the eagle, the snake, the cook, or even the king. It fell on the woman, who, without knowing the truth, passed judgment and spread it.

Her words carried a different kind of poison. One that stained the king’s name, intent, and honor.

When Patti ended the story, she looked at us and asked,
“Why do you think the curse fell on the old woman?”

We didn’t know then. But today, I do. 

She didn’t witness the event. She didn’t know the facts. But she repeated the story anyway, passing judgment along with it. And that, sometimes, is how karma finds you, not through action, but through the careless words we toss into the world. 

The Power of Silence

Gossip and judgment are like drops of venom, small, but powerful enough to destroy trust, reputations, even lives. And unlike physical wounds, the damage from careless words isn’t always visible. But it lingers. It echoes. 

Being human means being mindful. It means pausing before forming an opinion, listening before speaking, and choosing truth over assumption.
Not everything we hear deserves to be repeated. Not every silence needs to be filled.

Sometimes, the most dangerous thing isn’t a weapon, but a whisper.
A whisper that starts with “I heard…” and ends with a tarnished soul.

So before we speak, let’s ask ourselves: Is it true? Is it kind? Is it necessary?

And let’s remember the Moor Patti. She didn’t mean harm. But harm was done. 

Let’s be the kind of people who protect with our silence, not wound with our words. Be the ones who pause, reflect, and rise above the noise.Because in a world where everyone has something to say, the rarest strength lies in choosing silence, until the whole story is known.